Bicol Mail


EDITORIAL: More Clavecillas in CaSurECo II

January 16, 2014 by bicolmail in Opinion with 0 Comments

A summary hearing initiated by Branch 33 of the Regional Trial Court (RTC)  in Pili, Camarines Sur, presided by Judge Marvel  C. Clavecilla on Civil Case P-2547 for Injunction with Application for Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) has established the right of consumers-and-end-users of Camarines Sur II Electric Cooperative (CaSurECo II) to insist that their cooperative should be properly managed and judiciously run for and behalf of its member consumers.

The plaintiffs in this case are not just three brave ladies —- Genoviva Dimaiwat, Josephine Leonides, and Evangeline Laurente —— but all the consumers-and-end-users of Casureco II. The complaint filed by these three women before the court in 2010 and the order issued by the court on July 6, 2010 have gone literally viral among the consumers-and-end-users of Casureco II. These three women have personified how they struggled, inspiring each and every end-user of CaSurECo II to institute protests and who, before this case was filed in 2010, found themselves powerless before the powers-that-be and the continual increases in power rates imposed on them.

What is so marvelous about this case is that the plaintiffs have identified a worthy issue that has unified the consumers-and-end-users of CaSurECo II and that they have found a court that would listen to their pleadings.

What is so marvelous about this case is that Judge Marvel C. Clavecilla has virtually underscored the right of the court to review the power rates imposed by the cooperative —- and more virtually to review whether the cooperative is truly a cooperative which should protect the interest of the consumers-and-end users, not the interest of the Independent Power Producers or of the Energy Regulatory Commission or the National Grid Corporation or the National Power Corporation.

What is so marvelous about this case is that Judge Marvel C. Clavecilla is standing firm on what he ruled four years ago — that he had granted the petition of the plaintiffs, that he has issued against the respondent a writ of permanent injunction which has remained valid, effectives and enforceable to date. A judge of weaker stuff could have mellowed and softened his views on current issues. Not Judge Marvel Clavecilla.

While the city administration has been distressed on how to resort to legal technicalities so that the city can have its hand run the central business terminal or how the district representative in Congress could bring enough funds for the district, Judge Marvel Clavecilla has found an issue whereby he could give the consumers-and-end-users of the cooperative a good turn. Aside from instructing that CaSurECo II “shall desist and desist from imposing unannounced and intermittent power stoppages in any and all areas within the entire area of its coverage, except for just causes’ and that “any violation thereof shall be construed as a retaliatory act to be sanctioned accordingly,” the judge required the cooperative to post notices of this nature in conspicuous places in the head office and in towns covered by the cooperative.

Should there be more Judge Marvel Clavecillas in the Regional Trial Court, this would give hope for those who have less in life that they have more in law.

Leave a reply

Special Report

PAG-ASA Weather Center Latest Tweet
Comments from the Readers
  • bottes cuir homme moto: bottes cuir homme moto... Exciting insights, you should take into account doing a podcast on business and marketing and advertising.... View Post
  • Louis Vuitton Outlet Online: Louis Vuitton Outlet Online... Cannot believe the naive comments. You go and visit these places and you will see exactly what having this sort of communication means to the community. Alerts for all sorts of disasters... View Post
  • Theanna: I feel sad for young Kisha and her pretty picture, spoiled by a tirade of "the political monstrosity obtaining (sic) in our country..." And it's you, (writer with no name) not her, who "virtually hurled a challenge..." I'm not a professional photographer but I know a lot about it. If this was supposed to be a sunset, where is the sun? If you called it "cogon grass with flowers" that would have been more appropriate. If the picture was enhanced, it was overdone and unrealistic. View Post
  • Theanna: Thanks Judge for that timely and alarming info on the country's postal service. I thought that by now, things are much better than when I was there. May I add a few cents worth of fond remembrance of the late fabulous Fr. James Reuter, SJ? I never met him but my brothers and male relatives were all Ateneans and Fr.Reuter's name was often mentioned at our house. When I heard that Roxanne of Cyranno de Bergerac was being played by one of the handsomest guys in school, I had to see it. Also, my brother told us about the time our father and he met him on Ateneo Ave. After exchanging greetings, he asked father, " Is he your eldest son?" My father replied, "Oh no, my eldest son is a daughter." The whole family burst into tearful laughter. View Post
  • Theanna: Glad that you're back, Mr. Kenkoy. Missed you and my Bikol language lessons. My native dialect sounds foreign to me now. Kenkoy was my favorite pinoy komiks but I was caught reading American Archie when I was supposed to be following a book discussion in class. View Post
  • antonio pena: What a blissfull story, Thanks be to God. Happy New Year Sir, May our Lord God Jesus Christ be with us all always. Only God knows our destiny. View Post
  • Theanna: What happened to the news bits under this picture? View Post
  • Theanna: Thanks for the above concerns. I thought I was the only one who sensed something odd, since I read the news printed under the Business section on Nov.15. I posted a comment, after much deliberation, on Nov. 17 re the offensive word in the headline. My simple arithmetic doesn't add up to the expected results of this huge 3billion peso project. I feel like the child in Hans Christian Andersen's story of "The Emperor's New Clothes". I can't figure out how the people there can generate 100 tons of garbage a day. View Post
  • alejandro: ano an sanglit? View Post
  • alejandro: tukdoan tang magnoronegosyo sagkod magtipon an mga pinapadarahan kan mga OFW. bakong dalagan tulos sa mcdonald. pagpuli kan OFW, otot. sibot na naman magbuwelta ta mayo na naman nin kuwarta. View Post
  • Pastor Dan: Can we rely on the government to be able to address the perennial problem of hunger and malnutrition among marginalized children ? Your guess is as good as mine... I just thought we could be more introspective with the developmental role of privately funded NGOs. The NGOs can play a crucial role in addressing this issue... more so if the present dispensation manifest some tangible support for them... View Post
  • Engr. Efren Rempola: Tama ka dyan, Manoy Joel, bako man si Fortuno o si Aga Muhlach an mabugtak saimo sa Kapitolyo tangaring ibalik mo sa mga taga-Camarines Sur an harong na ini. Kun talagang habo saimo ni Aga, sa cuarto distrito, yaon baga si dating Cong. Wimpy Fuentebella asin an mga Alcalde na supotado ki Spkr Noli Fuentebella. Dae naman yan ma-iriba ki Gurang na Villafuerte ta aram naman ninda na drama man sana an labanan kan mag-amang Luis asin L-Ray. Sa quinto distrito (Rinconada), Manoy Joel, yaon baga si dating Cong Nancing Alfelor. Aram man sana kan gabos na Rinconada na iyo ini an tunay na LP bakong si Fortuno. Dae naman pati yan ma-iriba ki Gurang na Villafuerte nin huli ta bistado na an iwal-mag-ama na sarong pakitang-tao lang tangaring sinda-sinda na sana an maglaban sa eleccion, eh, ngonyan yaon ka dyan Manoy, dikit na sacripisyo na lang, hahalion na an mag-ama asin ma-ibabalik na an Kapitolyo sa mga tao. View Post
  • Winston Cigarettes Website: Very nice article, just what I needed. View Post
  • traqy: Wow! This will bring longterm economic opportunity to Naga City. Thus, the city will be more self-reliant and self-sustainable as power supply will be rarely disrupt even in times of natural disaster. More BPOs might operate in the city as the confidence on power supply is high. Good work Mayor John Bongat! View Post
Published every Thursday
Goldprint Bldg., Concepcion Grande,
4400 Naga City, Philippines
E-mail: /
Fax/Tel. (054) 811-1821

Entered as Second Class Mail Matter at the Naga City Post Office City of Naga, Philippines

Adjudged “Best-Edited Provincial Newspaper” * Member, Publisher Assn. of the Phils., Inc.
As of Today, this site has been visited asp hit counter times.
News Flash
  • Proyecto kan DILG paribok
  • SA NFA CAMSUR:  Nagpaseguro stock nin bagas sa bulan nin mga tingating
  • SA LP BICOL:  Leni bagong reg’l chairman, VG Peña, pamayo provincial
  • Mga mayong biometics data papadarahan surat
  • Pag-renew, pagkoa nin licencia sa badil gigibohon sa PNP CSur
  • 55 overloading na manga jeepney dinakop kan LTFRB
  • DAR Turns over P50M worth of farm machineries to Bicolano farmers.